This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Preorder your cheese and serveware

Thanksgiving Gifts to Share Around the Table

star star star star star
4.9 Stars out of 226 reviews

SERVE AND STORE CHEESE IN STYLE

Ultimate in Cheese Storage

The Cheese Grotto is the perfect way to temper your cheese before service, ensuring that your soft-ripened bries, washed rinds, and firm cheeses are served at their optimal texture and flavor. With its removable serving trays, it also doubles as a great cheese centerpiece for the Thanksgiving table.

Place your Grotto order by November 15th to receive it in time for Thanksgiving.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

BEAUTIFUL GIFT BOXES

Our Top-Selling Gift Boxes

Hand-tied with a bronze satin ribbon, these royal blue gift boxes are filled to the brim with artisan cheese and accompaniments, perfect for your holiday gathering!

For Thanksgiving delivery, order by Friday, November 20th at the very latest. All cheese orders ship via Two-Day Shipping. It is ALWAYS recommended to order to ship early, as carriers can experience delays.

MONTHLY GIFT SUBSCRIPTION

November's Monthly Box is Made for Fall Gatherings

Prepay for three months of a curated, rotating selection of 3 American artisan cheeses per month (about 1.5 pounds), with the option to add pairings and crackers.

For November's box, we're featuring artisan cheeses perfect for fall cooking and entertaining. This month's box features Laura Chenel's Pear, Wine & Rosemary Goat Cheese, perfect for a flavorful holiday cheese ball, Marieke Gouda's Limited-Released Extra Aged Golden, a crystalline Parmesan-Gouda hybrid, and Green Mountain Blue Madison, a rare small-batch blue that is both dense and fudgy. Add pairings to your order for Semifreddi's stuffing, plump, juicy apricots, roasted chestnuts, and thinly sliced heritage pancetta. 

Each box includes a printed tasting menu with recommended pairings, original recipes for stuffing, and a holiday cheese ball featuring the box ingredients, and a live recording of our cheese experts discussing the cheeses & pairings.

QUARTERLY "MEET THE MAKERS" SUBSCRIPTION

November's Meet the Makers Box is Fit for Thanksgiving

November's Meet the Makers Quarterly Subscription box is a beautiful addition to any Thanksgiving cheese course. The best part?  You get the chance to meet the cheesemaker live on Zoom on Saturday, November 21st at 4p.m. EST!

The box features four different small-batch cheeses from Black Radish Creamery in Granville, Ohio. The box includes their signature camembert-style Bankston, a gold-leaf flecked Gouda named Golda, a traditional-style meltable Raclette, and their vibrant orange clothbound cheddar Red Bandit. This selection of cheeses is sure to impress and satisfy all types of palates at your November holiday gatherings.

Order by Sunday, November 15th to receive the November 2026 Quarterly Subscription box. All orders ship Tuesday, November 17th.

À LA CARTE

Load Up On Cheese

From Thanksgiving cheese gift boxes to small-batch seasonal cheeses and pairings, you've come to the right place.

For Thanksgiving delivery, order by Friday, November 20th. All cheeses orders ship via Two-Day.

Shop Our Complete Thanksgiving Collection
 
 
 

Thanksgiving, The Perfect Time for Cheese

As Thanksgiving draws near, it's not just about the turkey and the pies. The heart and soul of many festive tables is the cheese board, a harmonious blend of flavors and textures. It brings warmth, elegance, and joy to every gathering.

Whether you're hosting a grand dinner or bringing a gift to a loved one, a thoughtfully curated cheese selection sets the tone for a memorable meal. Our Thanksgiving Cheese Gift Boxes are handpicked for the season — the perfect way to say “Thank You” and share the spirit of gratitude.

Tips for the Perfect Thanksgiving Cheese Board:

➡️ Serve at room temperature for the best flavor and aroma.

➡️ Include soft, hard, crumbly, and creamy cheeses for variety.

➡️ Add accompaniments like fresh fruits, nuts, jams, honey, or artisan crackers for balance and color.

Whatever cheese you choose for Thanksgiving, it's the spirit of gratitude and togetherness that makes the occasion special. So take a bite, savor the craftsmanship in every wedge, and enjoy the moments shared around the table.

Happy Thanksgiving, and may your festivities be filled with delicious cheeses!

Good Subscription Agency
Free Bonus Gourmet Item with Every Cheese Subscription Order. Sign up today.

Cart

No more products available for purchase

Your cart is currently empty.