This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Prepay & Save Cheese Subscriptions

*FREE Bonus Gourmet Item with Every Subscription Order (avg $10 value)

Our Regular Prepay & Save options are perfect if you're a committed cheese lover who is also looking to save on the price per box and shipping. 

Looking to gift the subscription to someone else? We highly recommend purchasing one of our Gift Subscription options below, as they offer the option to enter in the Name and Email of the Gift Recipient.  This will give them access to the subscription portal without sharing pricing or ruining the surprise.

Prepay and Save on the Best Cheese Subscription featuring American Artisans


Receive a bundle discount and shipping savings when you sign up for our prepay and save subscriptions. Purchase 3, 6, or 12 months of cheese at a time, with the option to skip or pause at anytime. Our prepay and save cheese subscriptions auto-renew after the pre-paid period, so you can continue to enjoy the finest American artisan cheese at the best prices.

Our cheeses are hand cut in order to ensure freshness and peak flavor. Whether you're looking for a gift for someone special or just want to treat yourself, a cheese subscription from Cheese Grotto is the perfect way to satiate that cheese craving!

Good Subscription Agency
Free Bonus Gourmet Item (Average Value $10) with Every Cheese Subscription Order. Sign up today.


No more products available for purchase

Your cart is currently empty.


Shipping Details


If you have purchased cheese hardware from our Grotto collection, it usually takes us 1 to 3 business days to ship your order, unless otherwise listed on the respective product page.

Cheese Orders

As the cheeses are a fresh product, we want to ensure the quickest transit time as possible, so your order arrives in the best possible condition.  Express shipping costs range from $25 - $55 depending on the package size, delivery window, location and carrier. We ship Mondays only each week, and orders must be placed by Thursday the week prior to be included in Monday's shipments.  If you purchased a cheese subscription with a set shipping schedule (Meet the Makers or any Gift Subscription), please refer to the respective product page for the fixed shipping schedule.

Please note: cheese ships from our cheese warehouse and hardware ships from our hardware warehouse. If you are purchasing both hardware and cheese, there will be a shipping charge for the cheese portion of your order.

International Orders

We are sorry, but we aren't legally allowed to ship cheese across the US border!  We can, however, ship our hardware from our Grotto collection worldwide.  Please note that the shipping costs options you see at checkout do not include customs, duties, and taxes which will be billed to you upon reaching the border, and will be an additional expense.  Those costs vary from country to country, but we recommend calculating at an additional 20% charge. If you refuse the package due to these additional fees and the hardware is returned to us, we will be able to issue a refund minus the outbound and return shipping costs.