This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Building #ThatCheesePlate into a Grotto

Want to make a two-tiered cheese board? Here's how to build one into the Cheese Grotto! This is just one way you can get creative with styling cheese and charcuterie boards. To make your cheeses and accompaniments look even more delicious, experiment with different materials: Try using slate next time, or swap out your Grotto Classico shelves for durable, sustainable PaperStone® shelving that doubles as a standalone black cheese board

When I designed the Grotto, I set an intention to make the cheese humidor as multi-functional as possible. This is why I designed the cheese boards with a slide function: the shelves can slide out partially for entertaining purposes, and can be removed completely for your dining table cheese board.  

Cheese boards and cheese plates are quite the sensation on social media. There doesn't seem to be anything as satisfying as a visually compelling cheese board. For proof, check out @thatcheeseplate or @cheesemongrrl on Instagram. The cheese board is a symbol of bounty and indulgence. Someone with a colorful cheese spread at their table is someone who made the right decisions in their life.

I wanted to share one creative way to build #thatcheeseplate right into the Grotto. The nice thing about doing this is that if under the rare circumstance you don't devour your creation in one sitting, you can slide the shelves right back in, shut the Grotto door, and save for later. 

beautiful cheese board tips

I featured all Cowgirl Creamery Cheeses in the two boards, as part of our collaboration through the month of April.

Here are my rules of thumb when building a cheese board:

1. First write out the characteristic of each cheese being plated. In this case:

  • Devil's Gulch, a bloomy rind cow milk cheese speckled with crushed hot peppers. This cheese is meaty, mushroom-y, and spicy. It is thick and rich in texture.  
  • Red Hawk, a washed rind triple cream cow milk cheese is robust, smokey, and nutty. It is also thick and rich in texture.
  • Wagon Wheel, a semi-firm cow milk cheese is light-bodied and creamy, subtle hint of almonds and walnuts in the flavor. 

2. When choosing flavors and textures for a cheese board, think about a balance of complimentary and contrasting flavors.

  • Devil's Gulch: The thinly sliced carrots serve as a palate cleanser, the dried cranberry provides a sweet, tart acidity that cuts through the cheeses richness, the seed crackers give a contrasting dense nutty texture as a vehicle for the cheese, and the prosciutto rosettes accentuate the meatiness of the cheese.
  • Red Hawk: The dark chocolate accentuates the nutty, smoky notes of the cheese. The blueberries and strawberries' fresh flavor counter the richness of the cheese. The sesame brittle balances out the extremely savory notes of the Red Hawk.
  • Wagon Wheel: This cheese is the most subtle on the board, so the fresh fruit, prosciutto, raw almonds, and sesame brittle are some of the best pairings to bring out the cheese's natural character.

3. Think color contrast as well as textural. It is important to be playful with your cheese board, as there are no hard and fast rules. The main rule: Eat more cheese, become more familiar with styles, and the nuance of each style will become more apparent for pairing opportunities.

4. Balance savory and sweet characteristics. I chose not to incorporate extremely brine-y, pickled things such as olives and cornichons because I chose fresh fruit and chocolate instead. In my opinion, pickles and chocolate are not that tasty together, and I like to make the full sweep on my cheese boards, and leave no cheese pairing unturned.

What's YOUR favorite pairing? Feel free to share in the comments below.

how to pair different cheeses

what pairs well with cheese

Photography and Videography by Jess Hitt


how to build a cheese board


Jessica at Cheese Grotto

Hi Bill,

Thanks for the feedback! I am definitely interested in working with Williams Sonoma at some point. The Grotto is made in the US out of high quality, sustainable materials, which is what makes it $350. I did write a little bit about this process here:

The Grotto stores up to 10 pounds of cheese, which depending on its use and occasion, could be for service for one evening for a party or storage for one month for a household of one to two people. We’ve had a few customers who would like something bigger, and a few have requested something smaller.

Please let me know if you have any specific questions!


This is a lovely box but how on earth can you justify the price? I get it. It’s exclusive. It’s hip. It also holds barely enough cheese for a small dinner party. You should really shop this around to Williams-Sonoma. It would be perfect for their next holiday catalog.

Erika Kubick

Girl this is so bad ass! I love your style and descriptions and this video is so charming. Thanks for helping us all eat more cheese!

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Good Subscription Agency


No more products available for purchase

Your cart is currently empty.